Skip to main content
CAT event update
For the latest on the Turkey earthquake, please visit our event page.
Learn more
  • Select a Site Blog
    US-Global
    Canada en fr
    United Kingdom
    Australia

    By Country / Region

    • Argentina en es pt
    • Australia
    • Belgium
    • Brazil en pt es
    • Canada en fr
    • The Caribbean
    • Chile en es pt
    • China
    • Denmark
    • Finland
    • Germany en de

     

    • Hong Kong
    • India
    • Indonesia
    • Italy en it
    • Japan
    • Malaysia
    • Mexico en es pt
    • Netherlands en nl
    • Norway en no
    • Panama en es pt
    • Peru en es pt

     

    • The Philippines
    • Poland en pl
    • Singapore
    • Spain en es
    • Sweden en sv
    • Taiwan
    • Thailand
    • United Arab Emirates
    • United Kingdom
    • United States

    By Country / Region

    • Argentina en es pt
    • Australia
    • Belgium
    • Brazil en pt es
    • Canada en fr
    • The Caribbean
    • Chile en es pt
    • China
    • Denmark
    • Finland
    • Germany en de
    • Hong Kong
    • India
    • Indonesia
    • Italy en it
    • Japan

     

    • Malaysia
    • Mexico en es pt
    • Netherlands en nl
    • Norway en no
    • Panama en es pt
    • Peru en es pt
    • The Philippines
    • Poland en pl
    • Singapore
    • Spain en es
    • Sweden en sv
    • Taiwan
    • Thailand
    • United Arab Emirates
    • United Kingdom
    • United States

    Specialty Sites

    • Broadspire
    • Catastrophe Services
    • Contractor Connection
    • Crawford Blog
    • Crawford GTS
    • Crawford Legal Services
    • Investor Relations
    • WeGoLook
  • Investors
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Subscribe
  • Login
    • CMS Portal
    • CAT Adjuster Portal
    • VTECH
    • XactAnalysis
  • Submit a Claim
    • US Claim Submission Portal
    • Text "Claim" to 877-531-4803
  • 24/7 Hotlines
    • ClaimsAlert Hotline
    • 877-346-0300
    • Transportation Claims Hotline
    • 866-420-1689
    • Submit a Claim
    • US Claim Submission Portal
    • Text "Claim" to 877-531-4803
Crawford & Company logo
  • Services
    • Loss Adjusting
    • Third Party Administration
    • Managed Repair
    • Medical Management
    • On-Demand Services
    • Catastrophe Response
    Global Loss Adjusting Preview Cards 480X270

    When loss occurs, Crawford is there with the right team, the right technology, and the right processes to help you restore and rebuild.

    Global Third Party Administration Preview Cards 480X270

    From loss adjusting to medical management to managed repair and more, Crawford delivers effective TPA solutions to save you time and money.

    Global Managed Repair Preview Cards 480X270

    Deliver a world-class experience to your customers from first notice of loss all the way through to finished repair.

    Global Medical Management Preview Cards 480X270

    A comprehensive set of clinical management programs focused on compassionate care.

    Global Wegolook Preview Cards 480X270

    Bringing the gig economy to the enterprise to deliver faster, more cost-effective results.

    Global Catastrophe Services V1 Preview Cards 480X270

    Industry-leading adjusters combined with innovations in technology and workforce management deliver value to clients when they need it most.

    Service Catalog

    Get details on all of Crawford's services in our easy-to-navigate online catalog.

    Explore our services

  • Industries

    Insurance & Risk

    • Carriers
    • Brokers
    • Corporates
    • The Lloyd's Market

    Other Industries

    • Agriculture
    • Construction
    • Entertainment and Events
    • Finance
    • Healthcare
    • Hospitality
    • Manufacturing
    • Marine
    • Mining
    • Power and Energy
    • Public Sector
    • Real Estate
    • Retail and Wholesale
    • Transportation
    Global Insurance Carriers Previewcard

    Optimize your claims processes and delight your customers.

    Global Insurance Brokers Previewcard

    Backed by our innovative array of services, you’ll always be the hero to your clients.

    Global Corporates Previewcard

    Comprehensive solutions for businesses in any industry.

    Global Preview Card Lloyds 480X270

    Exceeding expectations for syndicates, brokers, insureds, coverholders, and MGAs.

    Uk Agriculture Preview 480X270

    Understanding the ever-changing risks of the modern rural economy.

    Global Construction Previewcard

    Specialized expertise for those who build.

    Camera man filming a scene in a doctor's office

    Navigating the complex landscape of production risk.

    Aerial view of city

    Supporting the unique and ever-changing risks of financial institutions.

    Group of healthcare professionals meeting

    Delivering on our mission so you can focus on yours.

    Global Hospitality Preview Cards 480X270

    Driving efficiency, building customer satisfaction and protecting your brand.

    Batteries on a conveyor built in a manufacturing facility

    Keeping the engine of commerce running.

    Uk Marine Transportaion Preview 480X270

    Expert service in a complex, large-scale and high-profile sector.

    Mining equipment outdoors

    Global expertise for large-scale operations.

    Solar and wind farm

    Knowledge, skills and experience in energy, power generation, and renewables.

    Ornate columns outside a government building

    Innovation and data-driven efficiencies deliver value for public entities.

    Global industry real estate preview

    Exceptional service, information and reassurance in a fast-paced business.

    Delivery truck unloading at a commercial loading dock

    Managing risk in one of the world's largest industries.

    Global Transportaion Preview Cards 3 480X270

    Frictionless intake, rapid response, and comprehensive coverage.

  • Innovation
    • Crawford Technologies
    • Asservio
    • On-Demand Estimatics
    • WeGoLook
    • YouGoLook
    • 3D Property Scan
    • Digital Desk
    • Digital Assist
    • TruLook
    • Recall 360
    • Escape of Water
    Global Innovation Preview Cards 480X270 V2

    We’re not just embracing change, we’re leading it.

    Global innovation asservio preview

    Leading-edge estimate review technology that eliminates friction and ensures faster, more accurate property repair estimates.

    Global code preview

    Streamlined, accurate estimating from a single source.

    Global Wegolook Preview Cards 480X270

    Combining technology with an on-demand workforce to help businesses gather and validate information anytime, anywhere.

    Global yougolook preview 1 480x270

    Empowering policyholders to safely submit their own claims data.

    Global innovations 3d property scan previewcard

    Get a detailed report with measurements and information about the exterior of a property by taking just a few perimeter photos.

    Digital desk preview 480x270

    Access next-gen claims processing

    Global digital assist preview card

    Using Digital Assist, adjusters can quickly and easily request the individual services they need to close claims.

    Global Tru Look Preview Cards 480X270 V2

    Claims handling that adapts to your needs.

    Global Preview Recall 360 480X270

    Helping you prepare for and respond to any product recall.

    Global Escape Of Water

    Combining IoT technology with IICRC certified water loss specialists to deliver rapid and reliable response.

  • Expertise
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Our Locations
    • Leadership
    • Investors
    • Global Citizenship
    • Careers
    • Press
    • Blog
    • Contact us
    Global Our Story Preview Cards 480X270 V2

    Learn about Crawford's mission, vision, values, and the over 75 years of history that have made us who we are today.

    Global Locations Preview Cards 480X270

    With hundreds of offices and service centers around the world, Crawford is everywhere you need to be.

    Global leadership previewcard 2 480 X270

    Crawford’s strong and seasoned leadership team leverages its extensive knowledge and industry experience to drive our business.

    Global Investors Preview Cards 480X270

    Visit Crawford's investor relations website for news and information relevant to our shareholders.

    Global gcr preview 480x270

    We strive to make a positive impact on the communities in which we live and work.

    Global Preview Careers 480X270 V2

    At Crawford, employees are empowered to grow, emboldened to act and inspired to innovate. Won't you join us?

    Global Press Preview Cards 480X270

    Discover recent placements, company news and additional Crawford resources.

    Global Blog Nav Preview

    The Crawford blog publishes regularly on our people, our company and the industries we serve.

    Global Contact Us Preview Cards 480X270 V2

    We’re here to help! Team members around the world are standing by to assist you and your business.

  • Resources
  • Free Consultation
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Post
  • Blog
  • Post
  • Category:
  • All Categories
    • Company
    • Expertise
    • Innovation
    • People
    • Services
    • COVID-19
    • Legal Services

Wednesday, February 17, 2021

Courts continue debating COVID-19 business interruption coverage

2000x1000 us blogpost courts claims

The COVID-19 pandemic was devastating for businesses in 2020. And that devastation will certainly continue into 2021 as government entities enact policies designed to limit the spread of the virus. Since the beginning of the pandemic, the conflict between corporate policyholders and insurers has been whether the business disruptions resulting from government-mandated closures rise to “business interruptions” as defined under insurance policies offering business interruption coverage.

According to the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School’s Covid Coverage Litigation Tracker, at least 1,453 lawsuits over the availability of business interruption coverage have been filed in state and federal courts throughout the United States since December 28, 2020. By comparison, only 150 business interruption cases were filed relating to losses stemming from 2012’s Hurricane Sandy, the deadliest and most destructive hurricane inflicting nearly $70 billion in damage.

How physical loss or damage is addressed

In response to the SARS outbreak in the 2000s, many insurers added policy endorsements excluding losses stemming from communicable diseases from business interruption coverage. Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, many policyholders filed claims for COVID-19 related losses. As expected, the policy exclusion was enforced by the courts.

Policyholders having policies without a communicable disease endorsement have taken a different approach. They are seeking business interruption coverage for COVID-19 related losses by alleging a “direct physical damage or loss.”

Generally, business interruption insurance applies only where a business must halt operations due to physical loss or damage resulting from dangers such as fire, theft, vandalism, or natural disasters. One approach a court could take is to construe the language “direct physical damage or loss” to mean the loss of use or habitability. Another approach is to narrowly interpret physical loss to mean tangible harm or some type of alteration to the property’s physical integrity or condition.

Policyholders in jurisdictions that take the latter approach face an apparent insurmountable challenge. Judge Valerie E. Caproni in the Southern District of New York in Social Life Magazine, Inc. v. Sentinel Ins. Co. succinctly summed up the gist of those decisions when she wrote, “[the virus] damages lungs. It doesn’t damage printing presses.”

Other judges have written similar language:

Mena Catering, Inc. v. Scottsdale Insurance Co. – “Although the Complaint alleges (with much speculation) that COVID-19 is present on Plaintiff’s properties and has somehow caused an undescribed ‘distinct alteration’ to the premises, even accepting those allegations, the Complaint still fails to allege a ‘direct physical loss of or damage to Covered Property … caused by or resulting from any Covered Cause of Loss.’ There is no ‘direct physical loss’ where the alleged harm consists of the mere presence of the virus on the physical structure of the premises.”

Carrot Love, LLC v. Aspen Specialty Insurance Co. – “As other Courts in this district have noted when considering similar lawsuits, the Plaintiff here simply does not provide the Court with adequate reason to depart from the nearly unanimous view that COVID-19 does not cause direct physical loss or damage to a property sufficient to trigger coverage under the policy at issue here.”

Event cancellation coverage

Where there is specific coverage for event cancellation, the policyholder will likely be able to file a successful claim regarding cancelations caused by government-mandated closures. This means that there could be a positive outcome for theaters, performing arts organizations, and organizations hosting sporting events.

However, for the claim to be valid, the event had to have been scheduled during the government-mandated closure time period, and canceled with that time period at the insurer’s direction, according to Janis Hagenbucher, Managing Director of Crawford Forensic Accounting Services. Support documents, such as signed contracts, would also have to be provided. If these criteria are met, then the insurer can calculate the claim within the parameters of the government mandate order and based on the policy limitations.

Recent judgments that may impact U.S. coverage disputes

On January 15, 2021, the UK Supreme Court issued a judgment in favor of the policyholders in The Financial Conduct Authority v. Arch Insurance. The case interpreted the language of 21 UK policy forms issued by eight insurers, and it is estimated that 370,000 insureds are owed a total of approximately £1 billion.

The ruling states that policyholders are entitled to coverage for business interruption loss incurred due to shutdowns caused by the COVID-19 pandemic and the resulting public health measures taken by UK authorities. Observers believe that while this ruling is great news for UK policyholders, it is unlikely that there will be a significant impact on business interruption coverage disputes in the United States.

That’s because the ruling is based on UK procedural and substantive law and does not address the interpretation or application of the direct physical loss or damage requirement central to the disputes in the United States.

However, on January 19, 2021, an Ohio Federal District Court granted summary judgment to several restaurant policyholders. The ruling in Henderson Rd. Rest. Sys, Inc. v. Zurich Am. Ins. Co. determined that they were entitled to business interruption coverage for closures caused by COVID-19.

In this case, the language in the policy stated that there must be “direct physical loss of or damage to real property.” The court ruled in favor of the plaintiff’s position that, due to the government-mandated shutdown, there was a physical loss of real property.

Crawford is prepared

As the pandemic continues into 2021, more claims will be filed seeking recovery for loss due to mandated closures. Whether the claim takes place in the United States, the UK, or in any of the 70 countries Crawford operates, our adjusters and forensic accountants are prepared. With new in-house capabilities surrounding this issue, and ample resources for scale, Crawford is well-positioned to support insurers with business interruption claims and their complex forensic accounting needs.

Related posts

Crawford spotlight blog post John Karmozyn

Friday, February 05, 2021

GTS adjuster spotlight - John Karmozyn

Read more about GTS adjuster spotlight - John Karmozyn
2000x1000 uk blogpost adjuster life

Friday, February 05, 2021

The evolving role of the adjuster

Read more about The evolving role of the adjuster
2000x1000 us blogpost successful adjuster

Thursday, February 04, 2021

Adjuster 101: How to succeed at adjusting

Read more about Adjuster 101: How to succeed at adjusting

Crawford & Company logo

Services

  • Loss Adjusting
  • Third Party Administration
  • Managed Repair
  • Medical Management
  • On-Demand Services
  • Catastrophe Response
  • Full Service Catalog

Industries

  • For Carriers
  • For Brokers
  • For Corporates
  • For the Lloyd's Market
  • For Construction
  • For Healthcare
  • For Hospitality
  • For Transportation

About

  • Our Story
  • Our Locations
  • Leadership
  • Global Citizenship
  • Careers
  • Press
  • Blog
  • Contact

Legal

  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Employment Policy
  • EU Privacy Notice
©2023 CRAWFORD & COMPANY. All Rights Reserved.
  • Home
  • Services
    • Loss Adjusting
    • Third Party Administration
    • Managed Repair
    • Medical Management
    • On-Demand Services
    • Catastrophe Response
    • Full Services Catalog
  • Industries
    • Insurance & Risk
    • Carriers
    • Brokers
    • Corporates
    • The Lloyd's Market
    • Other Industries
    • Agriculture
    • Construction
    • Entertainment and Events
    • Finance
    • Healthcare
    • Hospitality
    • Manufacturing
    • Marine
    • Mining
    • Power and Energy
    • Public Sector
    • Real Estate
    • Retail and Wholesale
    • Transportation
  • Innovation
    • Crawford Technologies
    • Asservio
    • On-Demand Estimatics
    • WeGoLook
    • YouGoLook
    • 3D Property Scan
    • Digital Desk
    • Digital Assist
    • TruLook
    • Recall 360
    • Escape of Water
  • Expertise
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Our Locations
    • Leadership
    • Global Citizenship
    • Careers
    • Press
    • Blog
    • Contact us
  • Resources
  • More from Crawford
  • Investors
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Subscribe
  • Login
    • CMS Portal
    • CAT Adjuster Portal
    • VTECH
    • XactAnalysis
  • Submit a Claim
    • US Claim Submission Portal
    • Text "Claim" to 877-531-4803
  • 24/7 Hotlines
    • ClaimsAlert Hotline
    • 877-346-0300
    • Transportation Claims Hotline
    • 866-420-1689
    • Submit a Claim
    • US Claim Submission Portal
    • Text "Claim" to 877-531-4803
  • Search for Expertise

Interested in learning more?
Get a free consultation with one of our experts.

Complete this form and we’ll get back to you at the contact details provided.