Skip to main content
  • Global Regions
    • United States
    • Canada
      • en
      • fr
    • United Kingdom
    • Australia
    • Asia
    • Europe & Middle East
    • Latin America
    • China
      • en
    • Hong Kong
      • en
    • India
      • en
    • Indonesia
      • en
    • Japan
      • en
    • Malaysia
      • en
    • The Philippines
      • en
    • Singapore
      • en
    • Taiwan
      • en
    • Thailand
      • en
    • Belgium
      • en
    • Denmark
      • en
    • Finland
      • en
    • Germany
      • en
      • de
    • Ireland
      • en
    • Italy
      • en
      • it
    • Middle East
      • en
    • Netherlands
      • en
      • nl
    • Norway
      • en
      • no
    • Poland
      • en
      • pl
    • Spain
      • en
      • es
    • Sweden
      • en
      • sv
    • Argentina
      • en
      • es
      • pt
    • Brazil
      • en
      • es
      • pt
    • The Caribbean
      • en
    • Chile
      • en
      • es
    • Mexico
      • en
      • es
      • pt
    • Panama
      • en
      • es
      • pt
    • Peru
      • en
      • es
      • pt

    Additional countries served by Crawford's global network. Learn more >

  • Investors
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Subscribe
  • Login
    • CMS Portal
    • CAT Adjuster Portal
    • VTECH
    • XactAnalysis
  • Submit a Claim
    • US Claim Submission Portal
    • Text "Claim" to 877-531-4803
  • 24/7 Hotlines
    • ClaimsAlert Hotline
    • 877-346-0300
    • Commercial Trucking Claims Hotline
    • 866-420-1689
    • Submit a Claim
    • US Claim Submission Portal
    • Text "Claim" to 877-531-4803
Crawford & Company logo
  • Services
    • Featured Services
    • Loss Adjusting
    • Large and Complex
    • Third Party Administration
    • Managed Repair
    • Medical Management
    • Alternative Inspections
    • Catastrophe Response
    • Additional Services
    • 24/7 Claims Intake
    • Accident and Health
    • Auto
    • Building Consultancy
    • Casualty / Liability
    • Contact Center
    • Contents
    • Counter Fraud
    • Cyber Risk
    • Data and Analytics
    • Directors and Officers Liability
    • Disability and Leave
    • Educational Services
    • Environmental
    • Forensic Accounting
    • Forensic Engineering
    • Global Client Development
    • Legal Services
    • OSHA Recordkeeping
    • Private Client
    • Product Recall
    • Property
    • Subrogation and Recovery
    • Temporary Housing
    • Workers Compensation
    Loss Adjusting

    When loss occurs, Crawford is there with the right team, the right technology, and the right processes to help you restore and rebuild.

    Oil rig on fire in the middle of the ocean

    Technical expertise and established partnerships to properly assess, collaborate, and resolve even the most complex claims.

    Global Third Party Administration Preview Cards 480X270

    From loss adjusting to medical management to managed repair and more, Crawford delivers effective TPA solutions to save you time and money.

    Global Managed Repair Preview Cards 480X270

    Deliver a world-class experience to your customers from first notice of loss all the way through to finished repair.

    Global Medical Management Preview Cards 480X270

    A comprehensive set of clinical management programs focused on compassionate care.

    Ais preview 480x270

    Deploying inspectors through a variety of networks to gather claims information faster and more efficiently than ever before.

    Crawford Catastrophe Services

    Industry-leading adjusters combined with innovations in technology and workforce management deliver value to clients when they need it most.

    Global Service Offering 24 7 Claims Intake Preview 480X270

    Faster claims intake means faster response — and faster response means better claimant and policyholder satisfaction... and lower claims cost.

    Global Service Offering Accident Health Affinity Preview 480X270

    With the ability to scale and customize to your specific business needs, Crawford can deliver claims handling solutions very few businesses or…

    Global Service Offering Auto Preview 480X270 V2

    Crawford’s auto services division is driven to resolve vehicle claims quickly and accurately the first time.

    Global services building consultancy preview

    A concierge-level solution for large and complex loss management through a nationwide network of expert commercial contractors.

    Global Service Offering Casualty Liability Preview 480X270

    With so many variables, casualty and liability claims can stifle productivity. Crawford blends innovation and expertise to deliver…

    Workers in a contact center responding to incoming phone calls.

    Crawford’s state-of-the-art global contact center combines the latest telephonic advances with highly trained professionals to deliver an…

    Global contents services previewcard

    Scalable for all types of losses, Crawford contents provides a turnkey recovery program to get policyholders back to life.

    Criminal using stolen credit card to commit fraud

    Crawford provides a counter fraud service that is truly unique in the marketplace from first notification of loss to the court of appeal.

    Global Service Offering Cyber Risk Preview 480X270

    Crawford’s Global Technical Services (GTS) group specializes in responding to and mitigating the damage from cyber-related events.

    Globalservice Offering Data Analytics Preview 480X270

    With an industry-leading analytical approach, Crawford can reduce overall claims cost and add efficiency to your claims management processes.

    Executives gathered around a conference room table

    Our team of highly experienced and multilingual adjusters, including those with legal and accounting backgrounds, manages a variety of D&O and…

    Global Service Offering Disability Leave Preview 480X270

    Crawford’s highly experienced team of professionals and comprehensive scope of services offer a great way to facilitate employee recovery and…

    Global Service Offering Educational Service Preview 480X270

    Crawford was founded on the idea that “knowledge and creativity is power” and for nearly 80 years, we’ve focused on education and training as…

    Beautiful rural country landscape

    Backed by extensive technical expertise, our adjusting and claims management service offers a fully-integrated, global solution to pollution…

    Global Service Offering Forensic Accounting Preview 480X270

    At Crawford & Company, our Global Technical Services group delivers forensic accounting expertise through its roster of specialized professionals.

    Forensic engineers working on a job site

    Our team of forensic engineers has extensive experience identifying a variety of civil and structural engineering and construction related…

    Uk Global Client Preview 480X270

    The Global Client Development team specializes in designing, implementing and managing multi-national and global claims management programs to…

    Crawford Legal Services

    Crawford Legal Services is reimagining legal solutions, offering a range of integrated and unbundled legal services both locally and globally.…

    Global service osha recordkeeping preview

    Broadspire’s integrated OSHA service offering completely offloads all of your data collection, log creation and recordability decisions.

    Global Pcs Preview 480X270

    Crawford & Company has developed premium private client services tailored to the diverse and complex requirements of our high net worth customers.

    Global Preview Recall 360 480X270

    Crawford & Company can help your business plan for, respond to, and mitigate the impact of any product recall. Designed with modular…

    Global Service Offering Property Preview 480X270

    Restoring and rebuilding foundations for businesses and individuals around the world.

    Us subrogation preview card 480x270

    Don’t let missed opportunities for a full recovery affect your bottom line. Our loss specialists will investigate, evaluate, and communicate…

    Craw temp housing preview 480 270

    When catastrophic events render a policyholder's home uninhabitable, Crawford's temporary housing services swiftly step in to provide…

    Global Service Offering Workers Compensation Preview 480X270

    Ensuring the right care for your claimants and the most efficient processes for your business.

  • Industries
    • Insurance & Risk
    • Carriers
    • Brokers
    • Corporates
    • The Lloyd's Market
    • Other Industries
    • Agriculture
    • Construction
    • Entertainment and Events
    • Finance
    • Healthcare
    • Hospitality
    • Manufacturing
    • Marine
    • Mining
    • Power and Renewable Energy
    • Public Sector
    • Real Estate
    • Retail and Wholesale
    • Transportation
    Global Insurance Carriers Previewcard

    Optimize your claims processes and delight your customers.

    Global Insurance Brokers Previewcard

    Backed by our innovative array of services, you’ll always be the hero to your clients.

    Global Corporates Previewcard

    Comprehensive solutions for businesses in any industry.

    Global Preview Card Lloyds 480X270

    Exceeding expectations for syndicates, brokers, insureds, coverholders, and MGAs.

    Uk Agriculture Preview 480X270

    Modern agribusiness is expansive and extraordinarily complex. Crawford's agriculture practice understands this and delivers needed expertise…

    Global Construction Previewcard

    For over 77 years, Crawford has solved the world’s most complex claims handling challenges, including those of our many construction industry…

    Camera man filming a scene in a doctor's office

    The media and entertainment industry has never been larger or more complex, encompassing high degrees of risk, unpredictability, and potential…

    Aerial view of city

    With dedicated specialists in cyber risk, forensic accounting, and many other specialties, in addition to its focus on regulatory compliance…

    Group of healthcare professionals meeting

    Beginning at implementation and continuing to claim resolution, Crawford and its global TPA, Broadspire, provide specialized protocols to…

    Global Hospitality Preview Cards 480X270

    Crawford's extensive capabilities and wide range of services are a perfect match for businesses in the hospitality sector. We combine over 75…

    Batteries on a conveyor built in a manufacturing facility

    At Crawford, we understand the extensive needs of manufacturers and offer a suite of services designed to support their operations and…

    Crawford Marine & Transportation

    With a dedicated, global marine team consisting of hundreds of experts, our services are comprehensive and specialized. Whatever the scale of…

    Mining equipment outdoors

    From massive landslides in an open pit mine to barricade failures causing fatalities underground, Crawford understands the unique needs of…

    Solar and wind farm

    The world of power and energy has never been more dynamic. Insurance coverage in this industry is as complex as the potentially staggering…

    Ornate columns outside a government building

    Crawford & Company supports public sector entities with innovations that increase efficiencies while offering the transparency, regulatory…

    Luxury apartment building in city

    Crawford offers dedicated, commercially-focused services for the real estate industry, placing pro-active settlement, regular communication…

    Delivery truck unloading at a commercial loading dock

    Crawford offers the depth of experience needed to solve the unique risk-related challenges facing the retail and wholesale industries.

    Global Transportaion Preview Cards 3 480X270

    When your business depends on moving, Crawford is here to keep the wheels in motion.

  • Innovation
    • Overview
    • Innovation Home
    • Explore Technologies
    • Asservio
    • Digital Desk
    • YouGoLook
    • 3D Property Scan
    • Digital Assist
    • Escape of Water
    • CoverAI
    • Renovo
    • WeGoLook
    Global innovation preview

    More than just technology: it takes proven expertise to transform how claims and risk are managed.

    Global innovation asservio preview

    Asservio is Crawford’s leading-edge estimate review technology that eliminates friction and ensures faster, more accurate property repair estimates.

    Digital desk preview 480x270

    Digital Desk is a one-of-a-kind, automated, single-portal claims adjusting platform packed with robust features and integrates with leading…

    Global yougolook preview 1 480x270

    Designed with policyholders in mind, YouGoLook guides users step-by-step as they capture the images and information required to document their…

    Global innovations 3d property scan previewcard

    Through a partnership with HOVER, Crawford provides customers and their policyholders exclusive access to the next generation of innovative…

    Global digital assist preview card

    Crawford Digital Assist makes available a wealth of claims handling solutions to support your desk adjusting operations.

    Global Escape Of Water

    Crawford’s Escape of Water solution combines IoT technology with proven services to deliver a rapid and reliable response at the first sign of…

    Global innovation coverai preview

    CoverAI: Revolutionizing claims management through AI innovation and empowering faster, more accurate claim coverage decisions with…

    Screenshot of Renovo Adjuster Platform

    RENOVO is Crawford's catastrophe portal, empowering our adjusters, employees and clients with leading-edge technology.

    Global Wegolook Preview Cards 480X270

    Instantly connecting claims handlers with networks of specialized, on-demand resources.

  • Expertise
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Our Locations
    • Network Providers
    • Leadership
    • Global Citizenship
    • Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
    • Careers
    • Press
    • Contact us
    Global Our Story Preview Cards 480X270 V2

    For over 80 years, our guiding principles have been embedded in Crawford’s culture, shaping the company’s ongoing commitment to putting people…

    Global Locations Preview Cards 480X270

    With hundreds of offices and service centers around the world, Crawford is everywhere you need to be.

    Circles filled with human faces scattered across a globe

    Crawford's scale and reputation allow us to build strategic relationships with true experts in their industries and their specific locales,…

    Global leadership previewcard 2 480 X270

    Meet our Executive Leadership Team and other leaders of Crawford's worldwide organization.

    Expansive roadway near to windmills

    At Crawford, we’re moving in the right direction. More than ever, we are committed to acting sustainably and responsibly by focusing on three…

    Diverse group of co-workers sitting around a conference table

    At Crawford, we're fostering a culture where diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) are at the heart of our values and play an integral part in…

    Global Preview Careers 480X270 V2

    At Crawford, employees are empowered to grow, emboldened to act and inspired to innovate. Our industry-leading team pioneers new solutions for…

    Global Press Preview Cards 480X270

    Discover recent placements, company news and additional Crawford resources.

    Global Contact Us Preview Cards 480X270 V2

    We’re here to help! Team members around the world are standing by to assist you and your business.

  • Resources
  • Free Consultation
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Post
  • Category:
    • Company
    • Expertise
    • Innovation
    • People
    • Services
    • COVID-19
    • Legal Services

Wednesday, October 28, 2020

The start of something big? Informed consent and the operation of CFAs

Blogfeature legalservices 2020

Background

The judgment in this case centres on whether solicitors should be able to take payment of a success fee from damages awarded to the Claimant. The case was for damages for personal injury arising out of a road traffic accident and was made under the Pre-Action Protocol for Low Value Personal Injury Claims in Road Traffic Accidents. There was a Conditional Fee Agreement in place.

The claim was settled following submission of the Stage 2 Settlement Pack for £1,916.98 in damages, plus fixed costs and disbursements of £1,783.19. The Claimant’s solicitors, CAM Legal Services Ltd (“CAM”) took £385.50 from the amount paid to the Claimant, Darya Belsner (“Belsner”) which represented a success fee of 25% of the damages recovered pursuant to the terms of the CFA which capped the success fee and which formed part of the retainer between Belsner and CAM.

Belsner challenged the deduction. Between solicitor and client S.74 (3) of the Solicitors Act prevents payment of more than would be payable between parties – unless the rules of court permit. CPR 46.9 (2) allows a greater sum to be payable as long as there is a written agreement between the parties.

The Court found that Belsner was only responsible for the fixed costs to the level of £500 and that CAM was only entitled to charge a reasonable success fee on the level of profit costs recovered (being 15% of £500 plus VAT), the effect being there must be a £295.50 repayment to Belsner. Why?

The grounds for the decision

The court considered two pertinent aspects of the case. Firstly, it confirmed that a solicitor is a fiduciary in circumstances where the solicitors wish to take a profit by way of fees over and above the level of costs that can be obtained from the other side. Secondly, and because of the fiduciary nature of the relationship and the provisions of statute and the CPR it was important for the solicitor to have obtained the client’s informed consent to the proposed charging.

The Court noted that in the documents sent by CAM to Belsner at the outset of the case, CAM’s estimated basic charges (£2,500) were five times the amount (£500) which CAM might be entitled to recover from the defendant if the claim settled for less than £10,000 at Stage 2 in the Protocol. The Court concluded that this ought to have been brought specifically to Belsner’s attention, if she was to give informed consent to the agreement insofar as it permitted payment to CAM of an amount of costs greater than that which she could have recovered.

CAM asserted that, notwithstanding that they did not do so, by the terms of their retainer, they were entitled to take more than the total damages obtained. It is clear from the judgment that any such argument would not meet with success.

CAM has reportedly already said that the decision will be challenged in the Court of Appeal.

What lies ahead? The next PPI?

Apart from the appeal, Belsner’s solicitors are reported to have said that the judgment will potentially enable five million people to claim refunds of excessive success fees deducted from compensation under CFA’s in similar circumstances. Even allowing for an exaggeration in the number of potential Claimants and allowing for a lower average level of deduction from compensation, the value of the potential claims could run into hundreds of millions of pounds.

Response to Claims

When is the disclosure of information sufficient to ensure informed consent?

In this particular case, the Claimant was told in general terms that she may have to pay her solicitors more than could be recovered from the other side. There were a number of such general warnings. The court found this was simply not enough to obtain informed consent especially where costs of £2,500 were estimated and it was possible that settlement may take place with fixed costs of only 20% of that sum payable by the other side.

In future claims whether there has been sufficient disclosure in the retainer documents, and otherwise, to enable the provision of informed consent will depend on the facts of each case.

At present there is no easily defined yardstick to measure the sufficiency of information given.

Will the duty to provide information be variable in response to the lack of sophistication of the claimant? Yes, that seems likely. There may also be a different approach that is appropriate for commercial clients.

Are there causation arguments? In a breach of fiduciary duty case, instead of simply requiring a causal link, the court looks to see what would have happened if the breach had not taken place. This is not the same as the general rule on causation. However in this case no such arguments were raised as the issue was simply whether informed consent was needed and had been given. If not the statute and the CPR combine to limit the amount that can be paid to the solicitors by their client. Whether the courts will allow exploration of what may have happened had the breach not taken place is to be seen but it may well be that there is no room for such arguments.

If sufficient information had been provided and settlement achieved on a different basis would a lower level of damages have been accepted? If so can it be argued that this will balance out the amount claimed back in costs? It may not do so as the breach of fiduciary duty is directed at the improper profit earned by the fiduciary and the level of damages may not be relevant to this loss. Nevertheless this approach could always be argued.

If there is a potential/significant risk, claims can be ‘bought off’ by an early offer. Given that the Court of Appeal is likely to be considering this matter, it would not be advisable to be making any offers at present, although, assessment of the retainer documentation is advisable to enable a preliminary assessment of risk.

No doubt there will be attempts to make blanket notifications.

Informed Consent – when should it be obtained?

The question then arises as to when (and how frequently) informed consent should be obtained from a client. This will vary on a case-by-case basis. However, as a general rule, it would be advisable for solicitors to obtain informed consent:

  1. At the outset of a claim once an initial review of the evidence has been conducted by the solicitor
  2. Upon receipt of documentation which has a material impact upon the claim and the recovery of costs (e.g. Expert’s reports, medical records, incident reports, etc.)
  3. Immediately prior to issuing Court proceedings
  4. At all key stages of the Court proceedings (i.e. at the disclosure stage, upon the exchange of expert evidence, the exchange of witness statements, at the CMC stage and immediately prior to trial) and
  5. When an event occurs during the course of the claim which has a material impact upon the prospects of success and/or the recoverability of costs.

Are there wider implications?

The relationship between a solicitor and their client is one in which the client reposes trust and confidence in the solicitor. It is often defined as a fiduciary relationship. In respect of litigation costs, this recent decision is a stark reminder that, as a fiduciary, a solicitor is not permitted to receive profit from their client without obtaining informed consent beforehand.

Although the fulfillment of fiduciary duties will be assessed on a case-by-case basis, this judgment will inevitably place solicitors’ conduct on costs generally firmly under the microscope.

Is this problem limited to cases with a CFA?

The burden of complying with fiduciary duties when advising on the recovery of costs could widen the application of this judgment to more refund claims. The wording of CPR 46.9 is said to apply to every assessment of a solicitor’s bill to a client except a bill paid by Legal Aid. This means that we could see disgruntled Claimants from across the entire litigation spectrum coming to the fore and intimating refund claims against their solicitor. It appears that the principles in this judgment could apply to all types of litigation (including ‘big ticket’ litigation) where informed consent has not been obtained from a client regarding any potential shortfall in recovered costs as against costs payable by a client. Should this prove to be the case, we could see the birth of a monumental wave of refund claims against solicitors both with and without CFAs. Hopefully the Court of Appeal will restrict the possible ambit of the decision.

If that is not the case the principle could be taken further and we may see the courts directing their attention at solicitors who fail to properly budget claims from the outset in order to ensure that clients are given focussed advice on the economics and strategy of claims and can give informed consent as a result.

Conclusion

Belsner may be the start of a new wave of claims arising from solicitors working on CFAs but this is subject to what happens in the Court of Appeal. The claims farmers are eagerly awaiting the outcome. After the Court of Appeal it is possible that attention could be directed more strenuously at solicitors’ advice on costs more generally.

Related posts

Blogpost 2021 Q3 importance of communication

Tuesday, July 13, 2021

The real value of communication

Read more about The real value of communication
Blog Brexit Crawford Ready Feature

Tuesday, October 15, 2019

Brexit: looking beyond the deadline

Read more about Brexit: looking beyond the deadline
Blog Mentoring Millennials Feature

Thursday, April 12, 2018

Mentoring millennials is key

Read more about Mentoring millennials is key

Crawford & Company logo

Services

  • Loss Adjusting
  • Large and Complex
  • Third Party Administration
  • Managed Repair
  • Medical Management
  • Alternative Inspections
  • Catastrophe Response
  • Full Service Catalog

Industries

  • For Carriers
  • For Brokers
  • For Corporates
  • For the Lloyd's Market
  • See More Industries

About

  • Our Story
  • Our Locations
  • Leadership
  • Global Citizenship
  • Careers
  • Press
  • Blog
  • Contact

Legal

  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Notice
  • CA + US States Privacy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Employment Policy
©2025 CRAWFORD & COMPANY. All Rights Reserved.
  • Home
  • Services
    • Featured Services
    • Loss Adjusting
    • Large and Complex
    • Third Party Administration
    • Managed Repair
    • Medical Management
    • Alternative Inspections
    • Catastrophe Response
    • Additional Services
    • 24/7 Claims Intake
    • Accident and Health
    • Auto
    • Building Consultancy
    • Casualty / Liability
    • Contact Center
    • Contents
    • Counter Fraud
    • Cyber Risk
    • Data and Analytics
    • Directors and Officers Liability
    • Disability and Leave
    • Educational Services
    • Environmental
    • Forensic Accounting
    • Forensic Engineering
    • Global Client Development
    • Legal Services
    • OSHA Recordkeeping
    • Private Client
    • Product Recall
    • Property
    • Subrogation and Recovery
    • Temporary Housing
    • Workers Compensation
  • Industries
    • Insurance & Risk
    • Carriers
    • Brokers
    • Corporates
    • The Lloyd's Market
    • Other Industries
    • Agriculture
    • Construction
    • Entertainment and Events
    • Finance
    • Healthcare
    • Hospitality
    • Manufacturing
    • Marine
    • Mining
    • Power and Renewable Energy
    • Public Sector
    • Real Estate
    • Retail and Wholesale
    • Transportation
  • Innovation
    • Overview
    • Innovation Home
    • Explore Technologies
    • Asservio
    • YouGoLook
    • Escape of Water
    • 3D Property Scan
    • Digital Assist
    • Digital Desk
    • CoverAI
    • Renovo
    • WeGoLook
  • Expertise
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Our Locations
    • Leadership
    • Global Citizenship
    • Careers
    • Press
    • Contact us
    • Network Providers
    • Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
  • Resources
  • More from Crawford
  • Investors
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Subscribe
  • Login
    • CMS Portal
    • CAT Adjuster Portal
    • VTECH
    • XactAnalysis
  • Submit a Claim
    • US Claim Submission Portal
    • Text "Claim" to 877-531-4803
  • 24/7 Hotlines
    • ClaimsAlert Hotline
    • 877-346-0300
    • Commercial Trucking Claims Hotline
    • 866-420-1689
    • Submit a Claim
    • US Claim Submission Portal
    • Text "Claim" to 877-531-4803
  • Search for Expertise
  • Location
  • Global Regions
    • United States
    • Canada en fr
    • United Kingdom
    • Australia
    • Asia
      • China
      • Hong Kong
      • India
      • Indonesia
      • Japan
      • Malaysia
      • The Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Taiwan
      • Thailand
      • Additional countries served by Crawford's global network. Learn more >

    • Europe & Middle East
      • Belgium
      • Denmark
      • Finland
      • Germany en de
      • Ireland
      • Italy en it
      • Middle East
      • Netherlands en nl
      • Norway en no
      • Poland en pl
      • Spain en es
      • Sweden en sv
      • Additional countries served by Crawford's global network. Learn more >

    • Latin America
      • Argentina en es pt
      • Brazil en es pt
      • The Caribbean
      • Chile en es
      • Mexico en es pt
      • Panama en es pt
      • Peru en es pt
      • Additional countries served by Crawford's global network. Learn more >

    • Additional countries served by Crawford's global network. Learn more >

Interested in learning more?
Get a free consultation with one of our experts.

Complete this form and we’ll get back to you at the contact details provided.