Skip to main content
CAT event update
For the latest on the Turkey earthquake, please visit our event page.
Learn more
  • Select a Site Blog
    US-Global
    Canada en fr
    United Kingdom
    Australia

    By Country / Region

    • Argentina en es pt
    • Australia
    • Belgium
    • Brazil en pt es
    • Canada en fr
    • The Caribbean
    • Chile en es pt
    • China
    • Denmark
    • Finland
    • Germany en de

     

    • Hong Kong
    • India
    • Indonesia
    • Italy en it
    • Japan
    • Malaysia
    • Mexico en es pt
    • Netherlands en nl
    • Norway en no
    • Panama en es pt
    • Peru en es pt

     

    • The Philippines
    • Poland en pl
    • Singapore
    • Spain en es
    • Sweden en sv
    • Taiwan
    • Thailand
    • United Arab Emirates
    • United Kingdom
    • United States

    By Country / Region

    • Argentina en es pt
    • Australia
    • Belgium
    • Brazil en pt es
    • Canada en fr
    • The Caribbean
    • Chile en es pt
    • China
    • Denmark
    • Finland
    • Germany en de
    • Hong Kong
    • India
    • Indonesia
    • Italy en it
    • Japan

     

    • Malaysia
    • Mexico en es pt
    • Netherlands en nl
    • Norway en no
    • Panama en es pt
    • Peru en es pt
    • The Philippines
    • Poland en pl
    • Singapore
    • Spain en es
    • Sweden en sv
    • Taiwan
    • Thailand
    • United Arab Emirates
    • United Kingdom
    • United States

    Specialty Sites

    • Broadspire
    • Catastrophe Services
    • Contractor Connection
    • Crawford Blog
    • Crawford GTS
    • Crawford Legal Services
    • Investor Relations
    • WeGoLook
  • Investors
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Subscribe
  • Login
    • CMS Portal
    • CAT Adjuster Portal
    • VTECH
    • XactAnalysis
  • Submit a Claim
    • US Claim Submission Portal
    • Text "Claim" to 877-531-4803
  • 24/7 Hotlines
    • ClaimsAlert Hotline
    • 877-346-0300
    • Transportation Claims Hotline
    • 866-420-1689
    • Submit a Claim
    • US Claim Submission Portal
    • Text "Claim" to 877-531-4803
Crawford & Company logo
  • Services
    • Loss Adjusting
    • Third Party Administration
    • Managed Repair
    • Medical Management
    • On-Demand Services
    • Catastrophe Response
    Global Loss Adjusting Preview Cards 480X270

    When loss occurs, Crawford is there with the right team, the right technology, and the right processes to help you restore and rebuild.

    Global Third Party Administration Preview Cards 480X270

    From loss adjusting to medical management to managed repair and more, Crawford delivers effective TPA solutions to save you time and money.

    Global Managed Repair Preview Cards 480X270

    Deliver a world-class experience to your customers from first notice of loss all the way through to finished repair.

    Global Medical Management Preview Cards 480X270

    A comprehensive set of clinical management programs focused on compassionate care.

    Global Wegolook Preview Cards 480X270

    Bringing the gig economy to the enterprise to deliver faster, more cost-effective results.

    Global Catastrophe Services V1 Preview Cards 480X270

    Industry-leading adjusters combined with innovations in technology and workforce management deliver value to clients when they need it most.

    Service Catalog

    Get details on all of Crawford's services in our easy-to-navigate online catalog.

    Explore our services

  • Industries

    Insurance & Risk

    • Carriers
    • Brokers
    • Corporates
    • The Lloyd's Market

    Other Industries

    • Agriculture
    • Construction
    • Entertainment and Events
    • Finance
    • Healthcare
    • Hospitality
    • Manufacturing
    • Marine
    • Mining
    • Power and Energy
    • Public Sector
    • Real Estate
    • Retail and Wholesale
    • Transportation
    Global Insurance Carriers Previewcard

    Optimize your claims processes and delight your customers.

    Global Insurance Brokers Previewcard

    Backed by our innovative array of services, you’ll always be the hero to your clients.

    Global Corporates Previewcard

    Comprehensive solutions for businesses in any industry.

    Global Preview Card Lloyds 480X270

    Exceeding expectations for syndicates, brokers, insureds, coverholders, and MGAs.

    Uk Agriculture Preview 480X270

    Understanding the ever-changing risks of the modern rural economy.

    Global Construction Previewcard

    Specialized expertise for those who build.

    Camera man filming a scene in a doctor's office

    Navigating the complex landscape of production risk.

    Aerial view of city

    Supporting the unique and ever-changing risks of financial institutions.

    Group of healthcare professionals meeting

    Delivering on our mission so you can focus on yours.

    Global Hospitality Preview Cards 480X270

    Driving efficiency, building customer satisfaction and protecting your brand.

    Batteries on a conveyor built in a manufacturing facility

    Keeping the engine of commerce running.

    Uk Marine Transportaion Preview 480X270

    Expert service in a complex, large-scale and high-profile sector.

    Mining equipment outdoors

    Global expertise for large-scale operations.

    Solar and wind farm

    Knowledge, skills and experience in energy, power generation, and renewables.

    Ornate columns outside a government building

    Innovation and data-driven efficiencies deliver value for public entities.

    Global industry real estate preview

    Exceptional service, information and reassurance in a fast-paced business.

    Delivery truck unloading at a commercial loading dock

    Managing risk in one of the world's largest industries.

    Global Transportaion Preview Cards 3 480X270

    Frictionless intake, rapid response, and comprehensive coverage.

  • Innovation
    • Crawford Technologies
    • Asservio
    • On-Demand Estimatics
    • WeGoLook
    • YouGoLook
    • 3D Property Scan
    • Digital Desk
    • Digital Assist
    • TruLook
    • Recall 360
    • Escape of Water
    Global Innovation Preview Cards 480X270 V2

    We’re not just embracing change, we’re leading it.

    Global innovation asservio preview

    Leading-edge estimate review technology that eliminates friction and ensures faster, more accurate property repair estimates.

    Global code preview

    Streamlined, accurate estimating from a single source.

    Global Wegolook Preview Cards 480X270

    Combining technology with an on-demand workforce to help businesses gather and validate information anytime, anywhere.

    Global yougolook preview 1 480x270

    Empowering policyholders to safely submit their own claims data.

    Global innovations 3d property scan previewcard

    Get a detailed report with measurements and information about the exterior of a property by taking just a few perimeter photos.

    Digital desk preview 480x270

    Access next-gen claims processing

    Global digital assist preview card

    Using Digital Assist, adjusters can quickly and easily request the individual services they need to close claims.

    Global Tru Look Preview Cards 480X270 V2

    Claims handling that adapts to your needs.

    Global Preview Recall 360 480X270

    Helping you prepare for and respond to any product recall.

    Global Escape Of Water

    Combining IoT technology with IICRC certified water loss specialists to deliver rapid and reliable response.

  • Expertise
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Our Locations
    • Leadership
    • Investors
    • Global Citizenship
    • Careers
    • Press
    • Blog
    • Contact us
    Global Our Story Preview Cards 480X270 V2

    Learn about Crawford's mission, vision, values, and the over 75 years of history that have made us who we are today.

    Global Locations Preview Cards 480X270

    With hundreds of offices and service centers around the world, Crawford is everywhere you need to be.

    Global leadership previewcard 2 480 X270

    Crawford’s strong and seasoned leadership team leverages its extensive knowledge and industry experience to drive our business.

    Global Investors Preview Cards 480X270

    Visit Crawford's investor relations website for news and information relevant to our shareholders.

    Global gcr preview 480x270

    We strive to make a positive impact on the communities in which we live and work.

    Global Preview Careers 480X270 V2

    At Crawford, employees are empowered to grow, emboldened to act and inspired to innovate. Won't you join us?

    Global Press Preview Cards 480X270

    Discover recent placements, company news and additional Crawford resources.

    Global Blog Nav Preview

    The Crawford blog publishes regularly on our people, our company and the industries we serve.

    Global Contact Us Preview Cards 480X270 V2

    We’re here to help! Team members around the world are standing by to assist you and your business.

  • Resources
  • Free Consultation
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Post
  • Blog
  • Post
  • Category:
  • All Categories
    • Company
    • Expertise
    • Innovation
    • People
    • Services
    • COVID-19
    • Legal Services

Thursday, November 18, 2021

Gordon Walker, Head of Professional Indemnity & Financial Risks, Crawford Legal Services

The new six-stage test of tortious liability gets a test drive

Woman taking a driving exam
This case involved an engineer’s liability for employers’ reputation.

Background

In a recent case involving a Structural Engineer’s (URS) liability for structural defects, the court was asked to consider:

  • preliminary issues concerning the scope of the defendant’s duty; and
  • the recoverability of the claimant developer's alleged losses and remoteness.

Some 14 years after contracting URS, building developers (BDG) found serious defects in the development that presented a health and safety risk. BDG allege that URS were negligent in their design and sought to recover the costs of:

  1. investigation;
  2. remedial works; and
  3. damages for reputational loss.

Whilst the Judgment, in this case, applies existing law, it is one of the first examples of the Court applying the approach advocated in Khan v Meadows and Manchester Building Society. (It must be noted that the facts here were assumed and the decision was on a preliminary issue.)

Decision

The High Court confirmed that the six-stage approach is the correct approach to take. Although Manchester Building Society might be called a "professional advice" case, the Judge confirmed that ‘its ratio is applicable to negligence more generally, and not limited to professional advice cases’.

It was held that the purpose of the Defendant’s duties in this case extended to the alleged losses arising from the costs to the Claimant of the investigation and remedial works, but not to damages for reputational loss. The court struck out the part of the claim relating to reputational damage, but permitted the other pleaded losses to proceed to trial. They approached the six-stage test as follows:

‘Actionability’ (or, was the harm (loss, injury and damage) which was the subject matter of the claim actionable in negligence?)

The court found that, for conventional damages, it was actionable. A structural engineering designer is not, however, under a duty to avoid or prevent damage to the reputation of a developer. This would be an ‘unwarranted extension’ of the scope of duty, it being practically impossible to quantify in advance the potential extent of such a liability.

‘Scope of Duty’ (or, what are the risks of harm to the claimant against which the law imposes on the defendant a duty to take care?)

The risk of harm to the Claimant was the risk of economic loss that would be caused by the construction of a building using a negligent design. The fact that a Defendant owed a duty to take reasonable care in carrying out its activities did not mean though that the duty extended to every kind of harm suffered.

(Stage 3 and 4: Breach of duty was assumed and factual causation was not suitable for preliminary determination.)

‘Duty Nexus’ (or, is there a sufficient nexus between a particular element of the harm for which the claimant seeks damages and the subject matter of the defendant's duty of care as analysed at stage 2 above?)

The Court made note of the overlap between this stage and the second stage, and confirmed that it may well not be required as a separate step in all professional negligence cases. However, the Judge thought that the question was appropriate in a design case. The question is whether the harm suffered fell within the ‘type of harm’ encompassed by the Defendant’s duty of care. For the conventional losses, there was a sufficient nexus between the harm for which the Claimant sought damages and the subject matter of URS duty of care as the structural designer. There was not sufficient nexus for reputational damage, as that could not be characterised as "relevant loss”.

‘Responsibility’ (or, was a particular element of the harm for which the claimant sought damages irrecoverable because it was too remote, or because there was a different effective cause (including novus actus interveniens) in relation to it, or because the claimant had mitigated their loss or had failed to avoid loss which they could reasonably have been expected to avoid?)

Costs of remedying a structurally inadequate building were characterised as being within the contemplation of the parties at the time of contracting and were not too remote. Although at the time of finding and remedying the damage BDW no longer owned the building, it was found that there was no requirement for them to have been served with a third-party claim. There was also no contingency required in order for a cause of action to be completed.

It is interesting to see how the Court used the six-stage test to consider the issue of reputational damage. The key points raised are:

  • Structural designers are not under a duty to avoid or prevent damage to the reputation of a developer. It would be difficult to quantify in advance what the potential extent of such a liability would be, which ‘would have a detrimental impact upon a professional adviser's ability to obtain suitable professional negligence insurance.’
  • Consideration of the scope of duty does not require analysis of the subjective motivation of the claiming party in incurring the losses or expenses. The Court criticised the Defendant on numerous occasions for the subjective approach taken in their defence – they argued that all remedial works were driven by the Claimants reputational concerns, a subjective view rather than objective. URS had argued that the costs of remedial works were incurred in order ‘to mitigate an altogether different type of damage: Reputational Loss’. The Judge confirmed that, to characterise all the losses as reputational harm seeks to ‘insert the Claimant's subjective motivation into consideration of the type of loss arising’.

This subjective approach by the Defendant was also criticised in the consideration of the duty nexus question. URS submitted that the harm BDW seeks damages for had arisen where there was no legal liability for the cost of the repair works. The Defendant was criticised for confusing the subjective motivation on part of the Claimant choosing to perform remedial works, with the ‘type of harm’ suffered. The Court has now suggested a different way of expressing the duty nexus question: "does the harm suffered fall within the category, type or element of harm that is encompassed by the defendant's duty of care?” This seems to be an easy retreat into earlier tests used on scope of duty and may not find favour with the higher courts.

All in all, this is an informative first run out of the six-stage test which shows that although there may be some teething problems, for instance with the “nexus” test, the process works relatively well. Let’s see if further cases bring clarification or muddy the waters…

Related posts

Six HBA Legal lawyers have been named in the 2023 edition of Best Lawyers.

Thursday, May 05, 2022

HBA Legal home to 'Best Lawyers'

Read more about HBA Legal home to 'Best Lawyers'
People working together on signing a contract

Monday, November 22, 2021

Fraud Recovery: judgement for £39k including £15k exemplary costs

Read more about Fraud Recovery: judgement for £39k including £15k exemplary costs
Blogpost feature covid claims

Wednesday, July 22, 2020

The coronavirus and potential claims and causation

Read more about The coronavirus and potential claims and causation

Crawford & Company logo

Services

  • Loss Adjusting
  • Third Party Administration
  • Managed Repair
  • Medical Management
  • On-Demand Services
  • Catastrophe Response
  • Full Service Catalog

Industries

  • For Carriers
  • For Brokers
  • For Corporates
  • For the Lloyd's Market
  • For Construction
  • For Healthcare
  • For Hospitality
  • For Transportation

About

  • Our Story
  • Our Locations
  • Leadership
  • Global Citizenship
  • Careers
  • Press
  • Blog
  • Contact

Legal

  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Employment Policy
  • EU Privacy Notice
©2023 CRAWFORD & COMPANY. All Rights Reserved.
  • Home
  • Services
    • Loss Adjusting
    • Third Party Administration
    • Managed Repair
    • Medical Management
    • On-Demand Services
    • Catastrophe Response
    • Full Services Catalog
  • Industries
    • Insurance & Risk
    • Carriers
    • Brokers
    • Corporates
    • The Lloyd's Market
    • Other Industries
    • Agriculture
    • Construction
    • Entertainment and Events
    • Finance
    • Healthcare
    • Hospitality
    • Manufacturing
    • Marine
    • Mining
    • Power and Energy
    • Public Sector
    • Real Estate
    • Retail and Wholesale
    • Transportation
  • Innovation
    • Crawford Technologies
    • Asservio
    • On-Demand Estimatics
    • WeGoLook
    • YouGoLook
    • 3D Property Scan
    • Digital Desk
    • Digital Assist
    • TruLook
    • Recall 360
    • Escape of Water
  • Expertise
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Our Locations
    • Leadership
    • Global Citizenship
    • Careers
    • Press
    • Blog
    • Contact us
  • Resources
  • More from Crawford
  • Investors
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Subscribe
  • Login
    • CMS Portal
    • CAT Adjuster Portal
    • VTECH
    • XactAnalysis
  • Submit a Claim
    • US Claim Submission Portal
    • Text "Claim" to 877-531-4803
  • 24/7 Hotlines
    • ClaimsAlert Hotline
    • 877-346-0300
    • Transportation Claims Hotline
    • 866-420-1689
    • Submit a Claim
    • US Claim Submission Portal
    • Text "Claim" to 877-531-4803
  • Search for Expertise

Interested in learning more?
Get a free consultation with one of our experts.

Complete this form and we’ll get back to you at the contact details provided.